Eggnog Spiced Shortbread | Holiday Cookie Swap

Jump to recipe

Eggnog Spiced Shortbread

This post is part of a virtual cookie swap with other black food bloggers who LOVE holiday cookies. Check out the other fantastic cookie recipes at the end of this post. 

It’s Mariah Carey season the holiday season, y’all! Time to put All I Want For Christmas on repeat deck the halls, joy to the world and fa la la la la to the la la la! And nothing says Christmas more than Mariah Carey a plate full of cookies and a cup full of eggnog. Guess what? I added eggnog spices to my favorite buttery shortbread to create a delicious wedge of holiday yum. This shortbread wedge is #PeakChristmas or any holiday or occasion requiring buttery shortbread and a delightful mix of wintery spices.

Eggnog Spiced Shortbread

You won’t find an easier cookie to bake than a shortbread cookie. Four ingredients are all you need. FOUR INGREDIENTS, people — flour, powdered sugar, butter and a pinch of salt. Mix it all together and you get shortbread – a crisp, crumbly, buttery wedge perfect for your morning tea, or whenever your sweet tooth calls.

Shortbread is a blank cookie canvas. Seriously, it’s like the boneless, skinless chicken breast of cookies. It adapts easily to any flavor you add to it. You can dip it in chocolate or stir in chopped, toasted nuts, dried fruits (dried cranberry and almonds are my favorite), flaked coconut, crushed peppermint candies, or other spices — a little ground cardamom will blow your mind.

Just a teaspoon of spices elevates plain shortbread from good to great.  For my Eggnog Spiced Shortbread I sift in the spices typically used in eggnog — ground cinnamon, cloves and nutmeg. It’s tasty. Like, All I Want for Christmas is Eggnog Spiced Shortbread tasty. Make some. Give some as a gift. It’s perfect for packaging and people will ❤️ you. Or make it and keep it all for yourself. Give yourself a gift.

Merry Mariah Carey Christmas!

Be sure to check out my Molasses Spice Cookies with White Chocolate and more holiday cookies here.

Watch the web story here.

Eggnog Spiced Shortbread

Sift the flour first, then measure out 1 1/2 cups. You’ll end up with more than you need if you measure first.

Your butter should give slightly when pressed. If it’s too soft (the wrapper looks oily) your shortbread will bake up flat and may have a greasy texture. If you think it’s too soft, pop it in the freezer for a few minutes before using.

Round Cake Pan


Medium Bowl

Stand Mixer/Hand Mixer


Cutting Board

Bread Knife

The tools section may contain affiliate links to products we know and love.




Eggnog Spiced Shortbread

#ForTheCulture Holiday Cookie Swap

Dash of Jazz:  Tahini Sugar Cookies

Eclectic Thought Catalog: Grandad’s Tea Cakes

Margarita’s On The Rocks: Peppermint Chocolate Chip Brown Sugar Cookies

The Hungry Hutch: Easy Frosted Christmas Sugar Cookies

The Blenderist: Vegan Spiced Chocolate Cookies

The Hungry Hutch: Chocolate White Chocolate Chip Cookies

Kenya Rae: White Chocolate Chip Pecan Cookies

Sweet Tea and Thyme: Double Chocolate Andes Mint Cookies

Marisa Moore Nutrition: Flourless Brown Sugar Shortbread

Sweet Tea and Thyme: Gingerbread Whoopie Pies

Dash of Jazz: Candy Cane Cookies

The Hungry Hutch: Brown Butter Walnut Chocolate Chunk Cookies with Sea Salt

Dash of Jazz: PB&J Thumbprint Cookies

The Hungry Hutch: White Chocolate, Cranberry and Pine Nut Cookies

Eggnog Spiced Shortbread


3 Trackbacks / Pingbacks

  1. Christmas Cookie Recipe Collection - Black Food Bloggers Club by The Blenderist
  2. Molasses Spice Cookies with White Chocolate | Holiday Cookie Swap – Cooking Clarified
  3. Ultimate Holiday Cookie Swap Recipes - Beautiful Eats & Things

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.